Emerald packaging knows the meaning of green.

Our company introduced, with New Star Fresh Foods, the first compostable package in the produce industry. We’ve helped our customers slash their carbon footprints by shrinking their packages. Over the last five years we’ve worked with California legislators and regulators to develop programs to mitigate the impact of plastics on our environment. We are also members of the Sustainable Packaging Coalition and the ASTM International committee on biodegradable plastics.

We offer several solutions for those looking to green their products. One of the most effective, if not the most glamorous, involves simply reducing the amount of plastic used in your package. This can include making the package thinner, commonly called downgauging, or smaller. This method is the easiest way to raise your company’s score on the Wal-Mart packaging scorecard, a system the retailer is using to rate the sustainability of various packaging alternatives. We’ve also helped customers develop recycling messages they can print on their packages. This is an excellent, low-cost, alternative for companies using polyethylene (recycle logo “4”).

Biodegradable – meaning compostable – packaging has appeal in certain cases. Given that retail packaging requires good clarity, NatureWorks PLA offers the most likely alternative. This material, made by extracting poly-lactic acid from corn, produces film that has excellent clarity and crispness. We've made spinach, green onion, and spring mix packages using PLA-based material. We overcome PLA’s low oxygen transmission rate by laser microperforating the film. Emerald Packaging works with Novamont's Mater-bi resin, which produces a film that's soft and pliable but lacks clarity.

However all biodegradable materials have their drawbacks. PLA, for instance, tears easily. Cellulose based films absorb moisture, which causes the film to sag. Every biodegradable alternative adds at least 50% to the price of a package. Complicating matters further, availability, thanks to high demand, remains restricted.

These issues have prompted some companies to turn to what’s called “degradable” packaging. These films use an additive to help packages break down more quickly once they are landfilled. The cost increase is negligible – perhaps as little as 3%. It’s a way to be green for little or no price.

Unfortunately, going green like this has problems, too. Environmentalists dislike degradable films because they do nothing to reduce the carbon footprint of a package. All things held constant, the package still uses the same amount of energy to produce and ends up as waste in the end. Worse yet, if the package ends up as litter, it can be mistaken for food by animals and marine life as it disintegrates. And California law prohibits calling any package “degradable”,“biodegradable”, or “compostable” unless it meets the ASTM requirements for compostable packaging, which degradable bags do not.

We have one final alternative. By laminating a biodegradable film like PLA to a traditional plastic like polypropylene a company can gain some environmental advantage by building part of the package using a renewable resource, in this instance corn. By incorporating traditional plastics some of the negatives of PLA can be ameliorated. Polypropylene, for instance, eliminates the tendency of PLA to tear easily. As you might guess, however, this is a very expensive path forward.

So what’s a company to do? For now, reengineering your package remains the easiest path forward. Using biodegradable or degradable films can make sense but requires careful study. Our salespeople and technical manager can help you assess your options and figure out the best path forward.